Day of Japanese Philosophy
The Day of Japanese Philosophy brings together scholars to explore Japanese thought through questions of language, embodiment, experience, ecology, compassion and decolonisation. The presentations offer a broad and contemporary perspective, connecting historical texts and philosophical concepts with current debates on human–nonhuman relations, ecological responsibility and the global study of philosophy.
Add to calendar
iCal calendar
Programme:
11.00 Rein Raud — Suspicious singulars and absent quotation marks: digging into Dōgen’s concepts
11.45 Igor Lill — Three Lock Picks for Accessing Other Bodyminds
12.30 Miikael Lotman — Pure Experience: A Philosophical Accident
13.15 Lunch
14.15 Lucy Schultz — Expressive Bodies Born of the Earth: Nishida, Zen, and the Ecological Self
15.oo Niklas Söderman — Compassion and Ecological Crisis: Nishitani's Relational Ontology, Deep (Social) Ecology and Posthuman Cosmopolitics
15.45 Takeshi Morisato — Why Africanising Japanese Philosophy? Decolonisation, Double Consciousness and the Challenges for the Kyoto School Philosophers
16.30 Social gathering
Abstracts:
Rein Raud, School of Humanities, Tallinn University
Suspicious singulars and absent quotation marks: digging into Dōgen’s concepts
One of the most characteristic features of the philosophic discourse of Dōgen is its linguistic innovativity, but at the same time his texts often warn us about excessive intellectualism and criticize all (over)conceptualization of our relationship with reality. Dōgen’s own concepts reflect this tension, and are usually capturings of ambivalent and dynamic engagements with reality that do not combine into a logically well-made structure, while presenting themselves nonetheless as valid tools for maintaining a rationally rather than mystically grounded relationship with our environment.
The interpretation of such concepts is a difficult task in any case, but here I would additionally like to highlight two further complications for this endeavour. Just like all other texts of the time, Dōgen’s text does not have quotation marks, and this obscures the distinction between a reference to a thing and a reference to a sign or idea referring to the thing, which can cause a lot of confusion. The other problem is that of plurals: both in Classical Chinese and Classical Japanese these are mostly unmarked and if the plurality of a thing is important, it can be emphasized by other means. When that is not being done, however, we should not automatically assume that a singular is being meant, as this may lead to significant misinterpretations.
In my paper, I will present examples of passages where the insertion of quotation marks to designate a concept or the treatment of some noun or pronoun as plural will clarify the meaning of a passage considerably and also make it more rational, thus helping the reader to avoid excessive mystification of the text.
Igor Lill, School of Humanities, Tallinn University
Three Lock Picks for Accessing Other Bodyminds
What is it like to be a stone? Although contemporary biology is rapidly expanding our understanding of the worlds that open up to members of the animal and fungal kingdoms, can we overcome the ontological gap in our understanding of the non-sentient entities of the world? Taking as a starting point the claim that we can, to a certain degree, understand other human beings, in this paper I would like to gradually extend these points of contact to other regions of reality, whatever the ontological complexity or mereological scale.
In order to do that I propose three lock picks for accessing Other bodyminds: structural, performative and simulational, each of which originates in semiotics, Buddhism and video games respectively. The notions of the explanatory act, plants and trees attaining Buddhahood (草木成仏 sōmoku-jōbutsu), Buddha Nature (佛性 busshō) and a player's spectator mode are all intended to serve as building blocks for a possible new bridge between our worlds.
Any search for connection with other manifestations of reality can be understood as a search for long-lost distant relatives who, despite speaking a different language, nevertheless instil a certain sense of kinship simply through their presence. The practice of shifting between perspectives may become the mechanism for establishing a more holistic understanding of the Other — a perspectivist empathy. And although these approaches may not be obvious keys capable of easily opening any door, they may serve as lock picks, allowing us at least to try to open these other bodyminds.
Miikael-Aadam Lotman, School of Humanities, Tallinn University
Pure Experience: A Philosophical Accident
In late nineteenth-century philosophy, “pure experience” designated a philosophical standpoint associated with empiricism, positivism, and related movements. In this sense, it referred to a philosophical approach that sought to ground knowledge in experience rather than metaphysical speculation. Yet the expression also had another, more concrete meaning: it referred to a particular kind of experience. But what kind of experience could properly be called “pure”?
In An Inquiry into the Good, Nishida Kitarō famously describes pure experience as occurring “at the moment of seeing a colour or hearing a sound,” before any thought of an external object or a perceiving subject, and “before even judging what this colour or sound is” (NKZ 1: 9) While this description is frequently interpreted in connection with Zen Buddhism, its intellectual history reveals a more mundane scene: a young clergyman falling from a carriage. In 1897, Reverend Thomas Carson Hanna suffered a serious head injury and subsequently lost his acquired memories. His extraordinary condition attracted considerable attention among contemporary psychologists and philosophers, including Nishida’s former teacher, Motora Yūjirō.
I will present Hanna’s remarkable case and examine its significance for William James, Motora Yūjirō, and Nishida Kitarō. In particular, I will consider how Hanna’s condition informed contemporary attempts to understand the relationship between experience and cognition.
Lucy Schultz, University of Tennessee at Chattanooga
Expressive Bodies Born of the Earth: Nishida, Zen, and the Ecological Self
This paper develops an account of the self as an expressive, embodied being arising within a social, historical, and ecological world. Drawing primarily on Nishida Kitarō and Maurice Merleau-Ponty, I argue that subjectivity cannot be understood as an interior consciousness sealed off from its surroundings. Rather, the self emerges through reciprocal relations between embodied perception, expressive action, other persons, and the earth. Nishida’s concept of “acting intuition” provides a framework for understanding this reciprocity: in perceiving and transforming the world, embodied subjects are simultaneously shaped by the world they inhabit. His notion of the historical body further illuminates how individual selves emerge from accumulated social, material, and evolutionary histories. In dialogue with Merleau-Ponty’s account of the “paradox of expression,” I argue that creative expression reveals the irreducible intertwining of self and world. Nishida’s Zen-inflected conception of absolute nothingness and the Ten Oxherding Pictures further disclose the self as empty of independent essence yet fully embedded in the living world. Artistic practices exemplify this dynamic, showing how individual expression emerges through bodily engagement with materials, places, and histories. Ultimately, I propose that selves are “expressive bodies born of the earth”: singular loci through which the world perceives, transforms, and expresses itself.
Niklas Söderman, School of Humanities, Tallinn University
Compassion and Ecological Crisis: Nishitani's Relational Ontology, Deep (Social) Ecology and Posthuman Cosmopolitics
The aim of this paper is to explore how Nishitani Keiji's views on the formation of the self in relation to the world and the resulting relational ontology can ground or illuminate discussions of human relations in their wider, ecological context. To approach this issue, the paper considers Nishitani's standpoint in comparison to philosophical perspectives on Deep Ecology, social ecology and posthuman cosmopolitics, and how these may contribute to each other. Deep Ecology's biospherical egalitarianism is first viewed through Murray Bookchin's critical lens for its abstract approach to humanity and its neglect of social dynamics. Limitations to Bookchin's position, however, force us to shift towards posthumanist cosmopolitics to grasp how relational ontology leads us to considerations of distributed agency, interconnected ecological registers, emergent causality and vibrant materiality of the world.
Carrying over the focus on politics highlights the necessity of recognizing our co-habitation with the nonhuman world, which enables us to move toward a non-anthropocentric and ecologically conscious understanding of relationality and agency constituted via networks of human-nonhuman actants. Reflecting on the character of this kind of relationality returns us to Nishitani's understanding of our relationality rooted in non-differentiating compassion. Finally, the paper suggests that our connection to the world in this light should also provide guidance to our understanding of complex ecological issues like the migrant crisis, prompting us to reframe actants and their roles within the human-nonhuman networks that produce processes behind these issues. By shifting to compassion as a normative orientation, we can focus on distortions or failures of relational responsiveness in an ethical demand that arises when we encounter the other’s vulnerability and where such responsibility is being evaded.
Takeshi Morisato, University of Edinburgh
Why Africanising Japanese Philosophy? Decolonisation, Double Consciousness and the Challenges for the Kyoto School Philosophers
The purpose of this presentation is to ask how Japanese philosophy can be read to deal with the fundamental problem of "double consciousness." The concept of “double consciousness” was originated in Africana philosophy in the 20th century and has served as the methodological foundation for the discipline of world philosophies in the 21st century. It articulates how the structure of European philosophy is designed in such a way that non-European subject can achieve neither their unity of self-consciousness nor a coherent knowledge of themselves and the world.
When Japanese philosophy is introduced or researched in the field of world philosophies, therefore, it is theoretically asked to account for its decolonial potential and/or its application for an inclusive study of multiple world intellectual traditions, namely to show how it is contributing to the dissolution of the problem of "double consciousness.” In this sense, to deal with the foundational question raised from the side of Africana philosophy through Japanese philosophy is more than presenting a particular comparative study of these two intellectual traditions but to show how Japanese philosophy can overcome the limitation of western philosophy articulated in the larger theoretical framework of world philosophies. I will briefly outline the genealogy of “double consciousness” by introducing the key thinkers that were involved with its articulation (such as Du Bois, Fanon, Wynter), explain how it is reframed in the context of world philosophies, and then explore how recent advancement in Japanese philosophy, especially in the Kyoto School Studies, present some solutions while anticipating new challenges.